On April 1st, in the context of writing about a newly appreciated shortfall in Social Security funding by the CBO, I wrote this (with the part I wish to discuss in bold):
Here’s a prediction – [the sharply reduced Social Security surplus] will be revised to the worse in about 6 months. I base this prediction on my belief that more people will opt for retirement than are currently projected and that entitlement program tax receipts will be below current projections. Also, nearly every prediction by the CBO has been revised to the worse over the past year, so I am “riding the trend” with this prediction.
At the time, several people commented that they thought this prediction faulty and saw the possibility of the exact opposite as being more likely.
I based my prediction on two concepts:
- With jobs hard to find and credit tightening, many folks would simply opt for early retirement as a means of securing any sort of cash flow at all.
- Many folks would (rightly) conclude that sooner or later the government would change the rules – perhaps moving the retirement date out a few years or reducing benefits or both – and opt to retire early as a means of grandfathering in their own position.
I can’t say for sure which of these reasons is most responsible here, but it looks like #1 is the winner for now:
Confirmed – Social Security Deluged with Early Retirement Requests
On April 1st, in the context of writing about a newly appreciated shortfall in Social Security funding by the CBO, I wrote this (with the part I wish to discuss in bold):
Here’s a prediction – [the sharply reduced Social Security surplus] will be revised to the worse in about 6 months. I base this prediction on my belief that more people will opt for retirement than are currently projected and that entitlement program tax receipts will be below current projections. Also, nearly every prediction by the CBO has been revised to the worse over the past year, so I am “riding the trend” with this prediction.
At the time, several people commented that they thought this prediction faulty and saw the possibility of the exact opposite as being more likely.
I based my prediction on two concepts:
- With jobs hard to find and credit tightening, many folks would simply opt for early retirement as a means of securing any sort of cash flow at all.
- Many folks would (rightly) conclude that sooner or later the government would change the rules – perhaps moving the retirement date out a few years or reducing benefits or both – and opt to retire early as a means of grandfathering in their own position.
I can’t say for sure which of these reasons is most responsible here, but it looks like #1 is the winner for now: